Is There Any Evidence?)
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. The phrase, or near variations of it, have been around for more than a hundred years. It was given new life by a 1979 book by Carl Sagan and then applied to the question of religious faith. Many an atheist has used the phrase to state that belief in God is irrational. The existence of God would be incredible, after all, entirely outside the norm for the observable world that we are familiar with and therefore would require similarly incredible evidence to believe in it. And when one examines the historical and scientific record for that evidence? Crickets. For all His grandeur, God seems particularly bashful, never giving us a shred of verifiable proof of His existence.
This line of argument, however, misses the mark.
When one actually listens to true believers a very apparent pattern emerges. From their testimony we hear that they absolutely do have extraordinary evidence of God’s existence, even a tremendous wealth of it. And not just nice feelings and confirmation bias, either. There has been everything from hearing an audible voice, to the gaining of impossible knowledge, to a miracle that defies the laws of physics, to meeting with a heavenly messenger, to an inexplicable healing, to a sudden transformation of character, to some experiences that the believer is not even at liberty to discuss at all!
Again and again, believers give testimony that extraordinary evidence does occur, just that it occurs privately. The skeptic is correct that we do not have much in the way of externally observable and verifiable evidence as a matter of public record. The scriptures tell us that one day there will be great and public signs and manifestations, and that eventually the evidence will be so great that “every knee shall bow” and “every tongue shall confess” that Jesus is the Christ…. But right now, for whatever reason, God operates almost exclusively on a person-by-person basis.
Of course, one could argue that incredible evidence that only exists privately is more likely insanity, but then faithful testimony would be the greatest mass psychosis the world has ever known. Completely unprecedented in its breadth, as well as in its ability to manifest in people who are otherwise totally rational and sane. I’m afraid this sort of casual dismissal requires as much unverified faith in the skeptic as acceptance of God requires in the believer.
The Private Testimony)
From my own life, I have had my own personal and extraordinary experiences, too. I have heard God’s voice. I have felt Him operate on my heart. I have had Him unmake and remake me in the same moment. For the experiences that I have had, the evidence overpowering, such that disbelief in me would be entirely irrational and unscientific. But not a single other person has lived through those moments with me and will never be convinced of God’s reality from them. Those experiences are not for other people; they are for me and me alone.
Many times, I have wished that I could prove God to someone. I have wished that I could make the argument that was totally convincing to an outsider. But God’s wisdom is not my own, and He simply does not allow for that right now.
Convincing is not in my power…yet I do still evangelize and witness. In fact, I spent two years as a missionary doing nothing but that. But why did I make that sacrifice, and what could my testimony do, if not prove or convince? Well, it could prepare and invite. It could help create an atmosphere where the Spirit could come, and the Spirit was the one that could do the convincing and proving.
Whether the person I spoke to had a real and extraordinary experience with God was completely out of my hands, but it did happen, several times, and I even got to be there in the room one time that it did. That moment did not come because of some amazing rhetoric or arguments on my part; it came only at the end when the sister prayed directly to God and had a direct experience come upon her. That sister’s experience convinced her personally. My own experiences convinced me personally. Only your own experiences can convince you.
Perhaps, then, the mistake is not in asking for extraordinary evidence. Perhaps the mistake is assuming that extraordinary evidence must be transferable. Rather, it would seem that God loves us individually, and He seeks to give each of us a gift that is all our own. If you ever do receive that gift, it will be the single greatest possession you ever own.

