Predetermined Expectations)
I grew up in an active Christian household. Every Sunday, I attended church with my family. There was never any consideration of not going, and through my childhood I it never even dawned on me that that would even be an option.
Of course, at a certain point, I became a young adult and stopped living in my parents’ home. I started taking care of myself, making my own plans, my own decisions for the day. I remember it dawned on me that I didn’t have to go to church. I could just sleep in, or get chores down, or play. I could go once in a while, whenever I started to feel guilty about being away for too long. Or, I could keep going every Sunday, maintaining the same pattern I had been raised with.
I had a choice, and having realized such, my relationship with my faith would no longer be taken for granted. If I was going to remain a Churchgoer, it would not be by accident. It would be because I had actively chosen it for myself. And if I was going to become tepid in my faith, or backslide entirely, that would also not be by accident. It would be because I had actively chosen it.
I have heard that young adulthood is the point where many churches lose large swathes of their congregation, and given my own experiences at that time, I am not surprised. This is the age in which we give full autonomy in our culture, and for many Christians this the first time that they start considering other options. I have heard a lot of Church leaders asking how we can change this trend, how we can ensure we don’t lose members of our flock at this pivotal moment. Frankly, I think that ambition is largely vain. It is not a flaw in the system that there comes an inflection point where many people will leave. That is simply a necessary byproduct of choice.
Stronger Ties)
Having a choice means having the ability to choose the worse option. And there will always be some that choose it. If the ability to choose the worse option is removed, then there isn’t really any choice. And maybe that seems like a good thing. It prevents the bad outcomes. However, it also prevents all of the best outcomes. It prevents the possibility for growth.
Growth requires a choice. Character development requires deciding to do what is right even when there are other tempting offers. Church attendance is just one example of this, but there are countless others. No one is truly courageous until he has chosen it over a fearful retreat. No one is truly virtuous until he has turned down the option to act out his lusts. No one is truly good until he has faced the desire to be bad.
To have growth, you must have genuine choices, and genuine choices are dangerous things. It creates the possibility of falling away and failure, but it also creates the possibility of entering a new level of discipleship.
I have seen those who recognized that they had the option to stop attending church and chose to keep going anyway. I have seen those who first decided to step away from church, but later on decided to come back. And for these people, their status in the church is now real, whereas before it was only theoretical. Having made an actual choice, they are actually invested, they are there because they want to be, they are giving up something to make this a priority. They are attending church on purpose. They are successful, because they had the real possibility of failure.
There is no getting around this. Growth will always come with danger. The only way to remove danger is to deny growth, and that is an even worse outcome than failure.


