The Gospel and the Death Penalty- A Prisoner Set Free

A Different Pattern)

Thus far in this study I have noted that God created this earth life, defined its purposes, and introduced us to it as His gift to help us cultivate our souls to their full potential. Given all of that, He also has the right to determine when a person is so contrary to that purpose that they ought to be removed from this life. He also has the right to determine when the penalty is delayed to give the offender time to repent. He sets these bounds according to His wisdom, and wherever He does place them He is justified in so doing.

Looking at the scriptural record, we see that those bounds appear to have evolved from the Old Testament to the New. According to the Mosaic Law, adultery was one of the sins for which the death penalty would always apply. In the New Testament, Jesus seemed to make this law even more strict, proclaiming that anyone who “looketh on a woman to lust after her hath committed adultery with her already in his heart” (Matthew 5:28). So, did this mean that now the death penalty would apply to anyone who even had a lustful thought? One might think so, at least until the incident with the woman taken in adultery occurred.

And the scribes and Pharisees brought unto him a woman taken in adultery.

"Moses in the law commanded us, that such should be stoned."

Jesus lifted up himself, and said unto them, "He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her."

And they which heard it, being convicted by their own conscience, went out one by one, and Jesus was left alone, and the woman standing in the midst.

He said unto her, "Woman, where are those thine accusers? hath no man condemned thee?"

She said, "No man, Lord."

And Jesus said unto her, "Neither do I condemn thee: go, and sin no more."
-John 8:3-11, shortened

It is worth asking, why was adultery a sin punishable by death under Moses, but then when Jesus was presented the woman taken in adultery, he chose to extend mercy instead?

Reason for the Change)

I already spoke a little on this in the first post of this series and also in prior posts, but I think the important thing to realize is that Jesus didn’t, in fact, contradict the law as it was given. Nowhere do we hear him say that having death as a consequence of adultery was unjust. Nowhere does he say that his new law was “correcting” the old one. Instead, he told his disciples:

Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil. For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled. (Matthew 5:17-18).

Furthermore, Jesus’s statement “neither do I condemn thee” seems to suggest that he rightfully could. If Jesus, however, let the adulterous woman go without executing her, did a jot or a tittle of the law go unfulfilled? No. Because as it turns out, there was an execution carried out for her sin, only it was carried out in Jesus’s body and not her own. In that moment that Jesus let her go, he was assuming her place.

And this is not only for the woman in that one instance. Every adulterer, or blasphemer, or rebellious son ever since has been spared a death penalty. Not because the penalty was withheld, but because it was executed upon Jesus. When Jesus died on the cross, he stood in for the execution of all of mankind.

Change of Subject, not Policy)

The important thing to recognize here is that Jesus did not change what most people seem to think he changed. He did not change either the principles or the policies underlying the Law of Moses. The principle is that severe violation of the purpose of life warrants removal from that life. The policy is that a man must be killed for mortal sins. Now the principle and the policy still hold true, but the person is put to death in Jesus.

Mortal sins remain mortal sins, the wages of sin are still death, the law is still just as strict in imposing justice, all that has changed is the subject upon whom the punishment is exacted. By this, mercy can be offered to us without robbing justice one iota.

Note: I am aware that the authenticity of the story of the woman taken in adultery is debated. Even if it turned out that such did not occur, it is still clear that the Christian movement included deferment of the death penalty, and the reasons why remain the same.

Scriptural Analysis- Leviticus 19:20-22

20 And whosoever lieth carnally with a woman, that is a bondmaid, betrothed to an husband, and not at all redeemed, nor freedom given her; she shall be scourged; they shall not be put to death, because she was not free. 

21 And he shall bring his trespass offering unto the Lord, unto the door of the tabernacle of the congregation, even a ram for a trespass offering.

22 And the priest shall make an atonement for him with the ram of the trespass offering before the Lord for his sin which he hath done: and the sin which he hath done shall be forgiven him.

Today’s verses deal with a controversial subject: fornication with a bondwoman. There doesn’t seem to be any distinction in the language as to whether this is referring only to a foreign Canaanite woman, or an Israelite daughter who is an indentured servant, or both. In any case, the matter here is clearly fornication, not rape, which is handled elsewhere. Also, I say fornication because it fits are modern vernacular where the woman is unmarried, but she is betrothed, and in Ancient Israel that would have elevated the crime to the level of adultery.

In regular cases, adultery was an immediate death sentence for both parties. Hence the woman taken in adultery brought as a test to Jesus to see if he would approve of stoning her. But as we see today, this was actually only the punishment for free persons. The law recognized servants as not having the same privileges, and therefore they were not subject to the same punishments. As we have seen in several cases, the law was designed with protections around the vulnerable. In one sense it was no respecter of persons, condemning all for the same sinful behaviors, creating no class who could just get away with wrongdoing. At the same time, it would change the range of applicable punishment, always retaining the greatest penalty for those with the greatest opportunity.

Verse 20 describes the woman’s punishment as “she shall be scourged,” but this is a highly debated translation. The Hebrew word used here, בִּקּרֶת (biqqoreth), means “examination, i.e. (by implication) punishment — scourged” (Strong’s Concordance). There is nothing that actually makes certain that the word was meant to be scourged here, instead of investigated, nor anything that links it to the woman only. This passage could just as easily read “they shall be scourged” or “they shall be investigated.” Indeed, almost every translation today does use one of those other interpretations.

What is clear is that separate from whatever punishment is described in verse 20, the man involved in the offense would have to make a trespass offering. After this, both parties could apparently be forgiven.

Scriptural Analysis- Exodus 20:14

14 Thou shalt not commit adultery.

Another very brief commandment, this one forbidding married individuals from breaking their marriage covenant and having sexual relations with anyone other than their spouse. Of course, this one commandment does not cover the entire breadth of sexual sin. It does not mention anything about fornication, or bestiality, or incest, or homosexuality. However, just because all these matters are not covered in the ten commandments does not mean that they are not covered elsewhere in the word of God. Here in the mountain Moses received the foundational rules of God’s law, but there were other visits to the mountain, and other details yet to come. Leviticus, for example, has several chapters that cover the other sexual perversions that are expressly forbidden by God.

I think it is fair to say, though, that adultery is the root evil that all other sexual perversions are an extension of, and this explains why it would be forbidden first in the ten commandments. Calling out adultery points to the fact that sexuality is fundamental to the union between a man and a woman in the covenant of marriage, and so it is the perversion of that order that constitutes a sin. Whether we also pervert that order by having sexual relations before we are married, or with people that we cannot be married to, or with animals, it all follows the idea of breaking apart the marriage covenant and taking the things which belongs to it elsewhere. All sexual sin is in the spirit of adultery.