Extraordinary Claims

Is There Any Evidence?)

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. The phrase, or near variations of it, have been around for more than a hundred years. It was given new life by a 1979 book by Carl Sagan and then applied to the question of religious faith. Many an atheist has used the phrase to state that belief in God is irrational. The existence of God would be incredible, after all, entirely outside the norm for the observable world that we are familiar with and therefore would require similarly incredible evidence to believe in it. And when one examines the historical and scientific record for that evidence? Crickets. For all His grandeur, God seems particularly bashful, never giving us a shred of verifiable proof of His existence.

This line of argument, however, misses the mark.

When one actually listens to true believers a very apparent pattern emerges. From their testimony we hear that they absolutely do have extraordinary evidence of God’s existence, even a tremendous wealth of it. And not just nice feelings and confirmation bias, either. There has been everything from hearing an audible voice, to the gaining of impossible knowledge, to a miracle that defies the laws of physics, to meeting with a heavenly messenger, to an inexplicable healing, to a sudden transformation of character, to some experiences that the believer is not even at liberty to discuss at all!

Again and again, believers give testimony that extraordinary evidence does occur, just that it occurs privately. The skeptic is correct that we do not have much in the way of externally observable and verifiable evidence as a matter of public record. The scriptures tell us that one day there will be great and public signs and manifestations, and that eventually the evidence will be so great that “every knee shall bow” and “every tongue shall confess” that Jesus is the Christ…. But right now, for whatever reason, God operates almost exclusively on a person-by-person basis.

Of course, one could argue that incredible evidence that only exists privately is more likely insanity, but then faithful testimony would be the greatest mass psychosis the world has ever known. Completely unprecedented in its breadth, as well as in its ability to manifest in people who are otherwise totally rational and sane. I’m afraid this sort of casual dismissal requires as much unverified faith in the skeptic as acceptance of God requires in the believer.

The Private Testimony)

From my own life, I have had my own personal and extraordinary experiences, too. I have heard God’s voice. I have felt Him operate on my heart. I have had Him unmake and remake me in the same moment. For the experiences that I have had, the evidence overpowering, such that disbelief in me would be entirely irrational and unscientific. But not a single other person has lived through those moments with me and will never be convinced of God’s reality from them. Those experiences are not for other people; they are for me and me alone.

Many times, I have wished that I could prove God to someone. I have wished that I could make the argument that was totally convincing to an outsider. But God’s wisdom is not my own, and He simply does not allow for that right now.

Convincing is not in my power…yet I do still evangelize and witness. In fact, I spent two years as a missionary doing nothing but that. But why did I make that sacrifice, and what could my testimony do, if not prove or convince? Well, it could prepare and invite. It could help create an atmosphere where the Spirit could come, and the Spirit was the one that could do the convincing and proving.

Whether the person I spoke to had a real and extraordinary experience with God was completely out of my hands, but it did happen, several times, and I even got to be there in the room one time that it did. That moment did not come because of some amazing rhetoric or arguments on my part; it came only at the end when the sister prayed directly to God and had a direct experience come upon her. That sister’s experience convinced her personally. My own experiences convinced me personally. Only your own experiences can convince you.

Perhaps, then, the mistake is not in asking for extraordinary evidence. Perhaps the mistake is assuming that extraordinary evidence must be transferable. Rather, it would seem that God loves us individually, and He seeks to give each of us a gift that is all our own. If you ever do receive that gift, it will be the single greatest possession you ever own.

Seeking Signs- Path Before Destination

Finding the Right Approach)

Yesterday I spoke about those who require a sign before they will believe in God or consider changing their lifestyles to fit His commandments. Today I want to point out that God does not just want us to believe in Him, He wants us to come to belief in the right way.

As any teacher knows, it is not enough for a student to have the right answer, but to come by it honestly. If all the teacher wanted was perfect grades, then the best method would be to show the children how to find the answers in the back of the book. Obviously, what is actually wanted is for the child to find the right answer through work and understanding.

It is the same for God. The disbeliever who calls for a sign is trying to peek at the back of the book. He assumes that if God wanted him to believe, then God should take the easiest, most direct route in convincing him. And yes, God does want him to believe, but like the teacher, God knows that belief is only helpful when the child comes to it through work and understanding.

The Flattening of God)

When those that seek signs describe what they want from God, it is manifestations that are perceived by the mortal senses. Writing in the heavens, a booming voice, an earthly visit…these are all things that would convince through sight, hearing, or touch.

Right away, I can see a problem with this. We are already a lopsided people. We rely on our physical senses so much more than our spiritual ones. There are many who only observe the world sensuously. Who doubt that there even is a spiritual domain. Who believe that knowledge can only be obtained by inquiry of the physical senses. If God were to flatten His presentation into this physical domain, it would only reinforce that lopsided view. It would reward us for being overly sensuous. It would affirm that this temporal domain is the only one that matters.

But God exists on so much more than just the temporal domain. He is transcendent and spiritual, and He wants us to meet Him on those planes. He wants to reward us for exercising our spiritual intuition. He wants us to feel Him in our hearts without ever seeing Him with our eyes. He wants us to learn that a spiritual connection is even more real and intimate than a physical one. So yes, God wants us to believe, but He wants us to find that belief in a way that sets us on a journey of rich spiritual discovery.

Seeking Signs- How Far Will You Pursue?

Waste of a Miracle)

There are those that say they will only believe in God if He will show them an irrefutable sign of His existence. They say, “If God is real, and He really cares about having me believe in Him, and He knows me perfectly, then He knows that I need physically observable evidence of Him.” They suggest things like a message written in the stars, or God descending to the earth in all His glory, or a booming voice sounding from heaven. Those would be strong, undeniable proofs of God’s existence, and surely that would bring many more people to accept Him as their Lord, so why not just do that?

To that I say: And what will you do if God does not show up with these great, undeniable signs? Will you continue to pursue the knowledge of Him?

The answer: I will do nothing, and I will pursue no further.

And to that I say: Why would God ever waste His time on someone with that attitude? Why manifest Himself to someone so fickle and disinterested? Frankly, you don’t seem to actually care all that much whether God is real or not. Are you genuinely quivering on the edge of remaking your whole life to follow Him just as soon He shows you a miracle? I find that hard to believe.

Pattern for Belief)

People hear that God wants us to believe in Him, and from that they assume that the onus is on Him to do the convincing. But two things can be true at once. God can both want us to believe in Him and also be perfectly willing to let us go if we don’t care enough to take the first step.

To be clear, I do believe that God pursues on His end, but I also believe He always stops short of making us believe in Him. In my experience, He always requires us to make at least one step in total faith. We have to do something because we believe it is right, not at all sure that it will turn out well, and that is when He appears to us.

If, on the other hand, we see that step before us and say, “no, God, not until you show me a sign,” He will let us go.

Evidence in the Lack of Evidence

At key points in life, you must choose between that which is most beneficial to you and that which you know to be right. You will have to decide if you follow your conscience, even when there is no reason to assume a positive outcome for yourself.

It only stands to reason, however, that if you ever want to live in the hands of the supernatural, beyond the confines of mortal logic, that at some point you must make a choice just like this. Earthly outcomes follow choices based on earthly evidence. If you ever want a heavenly outcome, at some point you must leap with nothing earthly in view to catch you.

Thus, watch for these moments where there is no evidence that things will work out well, and in those moments take courage in the knowledge that the lack of evidence is the greatest evidence of all.

Scriptural Analysis- Genesis 38:15-18

15 When Judah saw her, he thought her to be an harlot; because she had covered her face.

16 And he turned unto her by the way, and said, Go to, I pray thee, let me come in unto thee; (for he knew not that she was his daughter in law.) And she said, What wilt thou give me, that thou mayest come in unto me?

17 And he said, I will send thee a kid from the flock. And she said, Wilt thou give me a pledge, till thou send it?

18 And he said, What pledge shall I give thee? And she said, Thy signet, and thy bracelets, and thy staff that is in thine hand. And he gave it her, and came in unto her, and she conceived by him.

The family soap opera takes a shocking turn as Tamar seduces her own father-in-law under the pretense of being a prostitute. As mentioned before, Judah had tried to pawn her off on her family, not leaving her many honorable recourses if she wanted to bear children, but this is still a highly unpleasant solution to her problem.

Fortunately for Tamar she thinks ahead, and tricks Judah into giving her all the personal signifiers that he is carrying. In other words, she takes his identity from him. And so it is with us whenever we give into temptation also. We do not only perform the act, we sell a part of ourselves to it. By her guile Tamar gained a position of power over Judah by obtaining direct evidence of his own shame. So, too, when we give a part of ourselves to sin, it gains power to drive us where we would not.

Our Own Reality- Question

There are eternal truths which we are powerless to revert. Things that will always be, and do not require our agreement to be so. However there are also things that we do get to choose about our reality. Thus if God exists, He just exists, and we cannot turn that off…but we can still elect to live a “Godless” life even so.

Indeed it is our common pattern to make up our minds about what we believe to be true, and then find the world reinforcing our opinions at every turn. Almost every situation is able to be construed to support both my reality, and also the exact opposite reality. The same event can be seen as proof that miracles are real and also as proof that only coincidences are.

With this study I would like to consider how we navigate this balance of truth vs personal lens. How do we tell the difference between God telling us something, and us just reaffirming what we want to hear? To what extent are we allowed to create our own reality, and what are the eternal verities that exist regardless of our opinion?

I’d be curious to hear how you have navigated between opinion and truth in your own life. How do you know when you stand on a foundation that is not just your own self? How do you answer those who would impose their reality over your own? How do you, in turn, share your truth without trying to force it upon others?