The Gospel and the Death Penalty- Summary

Who is Sovereign?)

This has been an interesting study to conduct, and I have learned several things over the course of it. The presence of the death penalty in the Bible is a controversial point, one that people use as justification in saying that the God of the Old Testament is a harsh tyrant who is eager to punish those that disobey Him. But that view seems based upon a perspective where one sees his own as sovereign and his right to life immutable, and not that God is the author of this mortal existence. Which is the first main principle that I found in this study: God is the author of our mortal existence and therefore justified in whatever bounds He sets upon it.

In my personal faith, I believe that we were premortal spirits who knew and lived with God, and to whom He offered an earth life as the way to cultivate our souls to their fullest potential. We who are on this earth are the ones who agreed to His plan and to His terms for it. As such, we entered life expressly so that we could fulfill God’s plan for it. When during the course of life we instead come out in strong rebellion, having God remove us from this life and back to the state that we were in before seems understandable and fair. But this is not the context that most people hold, and I understand why they therefore grapple. Many in this world view themselves as sovereign over their own lives, and this earth life as the ultimate reality. Both of those beliefs make a consignment to death a violation of what they see as a superior principle.

The Wages of Sin)

The second principle that I was reminded of is that it is not just some sins that warrant a death penalty, it is all of them. All sin is an act of rebellion against God and our better nature. It frustrates the cultivation of our souls and therefore provides the justification for removing us from this earth experience. We are not all executed at our first sin only because God has prepared a way by which we can repent and change over time, thus eventually fulfilling the purpose for which we were sent here.

So, it is wise for God to spare the sinner, but not necessarily for the most egregious acts of rebellion, and any time that He does execute justice it is fair and deserved. While we live in the hope of being perfected in Christ and receiving paradise, we must never lose sight of the fact that on our own we are worthy of death. That changes the perspective on God’s justice quite a bit.

Core Laws Never Change)

The third principle that stood out to me was that the fundamental laws of the gospel never change. Minor policies might change, such as the day for sabbath observance or the prohibitions against certain meats, but as we have already seen, the death penalty is inseparably connected to the principles of Law and Justice. Those have not changed and never will.

No matter how many sinners Jesus pardoned, it never dissolved the fact that sin demanded justice. It did not change that we all come in rebellion to God’s purpose for life. It did not prevent Paul from concluding that the “wages of sin is death.” All of that is still true, only now the justice, the death penalty, and the condemnation is executed upon the person of Jesus.

God gave the Ancient Israelites a stay of execution for minor sins, and now we have it for more major ones as well. But in all cases, it is only a stay, not a dismissal. In all cases justice does still happen, but now upon the Lamb of God.

Nothing New)

Laying out those three core principles, it became clear that I was repeating a very familiar story.

  1. God is sovereign over all and seeks to perfect our souls.
  2. Each of us instead goes astray and deserves judgment.
  3. But Jesus took that penalty so that we may repent and be redeemed.

There is nothing new in this, but perhaps by approaching that familiar story through something as difficult and controversial as the Old Testament death penalties, you have now seen it from a new perspective. I certainly know that I have.

The Gospel and the Death Penalty- Why Death?

Death Penalty Categories)

I have spent the last two posts addressing different categories of people who would be opposed to God’s use of the death penalty in the Old Testament. Today, I am going to take up the other side. Why would God use the death penalty? Are there justifiable reasons for its application to the situations described in the Bible? Let’s start by considering what those situations are.

God’s application of the death penalty falls under five general categories:

  1. Sexual perversion: adultery, homosexuality, bestiality, incest, etc.
  2. Violence: murder, kidnapping, etc.
  3. Idolatry: performing witchcraft or wizardry, worshipping false gods, leading others astray, etc.
  4. Disobedience to God: blaspheming God, working on the Sabbath, disobeying the priest, etc.
  5. Disobedience to parents: cursing parents, striking parents, stubbornly rebellious child, etc.

If I were to abstract this further, I think the category of sexual perversion could be called actions against nature, the violence category could be called retributive justice, and all of the other categories could be summed up as open rebellion. I believe that abstracting these categories is useful for understanding the principle of offense at the heart of them, the core thing in each that God is so opposed to. Let us look at each of these three abstracted categories in turn.

Three Underlying Principles)

The first category is sins against nature. God has created the world with a natural order. Each species reproduces with its own kind. Family units progress from one generation to the next. Everything fulfills God’s original command to be fruitful and multiply. Our nature is one of life and propagation. Therefore, sins that go against the natural order are actions oriented towards death and termination. The end of reproduction, the end of a family line, the breaking up of the natural order…each of these is a small death, and if adopted by a significant portion of the species would spell the end of it very quickly. Thus, those who engage in sins against nature, particularly through sexually deviant acts, are already agents of death, and it is fitting for a death penalty to be assigned to them. It is God recognizing the ends that these acts are oriented towards and enacting that end immediately.

The second category is retributive justice. These are sins that deprive another of life, and therefore it is only fitting that the penalty for it is also death. This obviously includes murder, but kidnapping and selling into slavery are also forms of taking another’s life, just in a more symbolic way. Even leading others astray from the faith is a sort of killing: the killing of the soul. That sin fits in this category just as well as the next. To require the life of those that commit these killing acts is nothing more than basic justice. It is an eye for an eye. You were willing to deprive others of life, so your life is required as well.

The final category is that of open rebellion. As with the first category, God gave us another natural order of hierarchy and power. Children are subject to parents. Citizens are subject to leaders. Humanity is subject to God. Instructions and care flow down one direction of the order, fealty and obedience flow the other way. When one comes out in rebellion, they deny their proper place in that order. They hold themselves as the highest authority and sever their link from the chain. Not only have they cut themselves off, but they make themselves an enemy to the established order. They wrest for control, which makes them a direct antithesis to the order. No order can continue if its subjects can defy it unabated. When rebellion begins, it must mean the death of the order or of the rebel. God has prescribed the death of the rebel.

The Final Abstraction)

Looking at all of these categories as one, another final abstraction emerges. God created this world for the cultivation of His children, to place them within an order and nature that encourage growth, development, and ultimately for them to achieve their greatest potential. That is the whole purpose of us being here. Each of these categories of sin directly frustrates that plan. They are inherently opposed to the continuation and cultivation of God’s children. When a system has been created for a purpose, then any subject no longer interested in participating in that system does not belong within it. If one does not wish to participate in the purpose of life, then being removed from life is understandable. Yes, that analysis is clinical and cold, but I think it is also logically sound. We are here for a reason, and if we no longer fulfill that reason, why we expect to remain here?

Of course, that raises some questions. Where is the line between simply being imperfect and not being aligned to our purpose for being here? Could the arguments that I have made today be used to justify terrible atrocities? It is also worth asking, if this is the system and the order that God has designed, then why was it removed after the coming of Christ? Why do we not follow this same logic today? We will dig into these sorts of questions in my next post.

Scriptural Analysis- Leviticus 20:6-8, 27

6 And the soul that turneth after such as have familiar spirits, and after wizards, to go a whoring after them, I will even set my face against that soul, and will cut him off from among his people. 

7 Sanctify yourselves therefore, and be ye holy: for I am the Lord your God.

8 And ye shall keep my statutes, and do them: I am the Lord which sanctify you.

27 A man also or woman that hath a familiar spirit, or that is a wizard, shall surely be put to death: they shall stone them with stones: their blood shall be upon them.

Verse 6 condemns those who seek the services of wizards, witches, or other occult practitioners. It mentions a penalty of being cut off but does not specify what that entails. The fact that God is the one doing the cutting off suggests this is a spiritual separation, not a legal action. But that is only for the one who goes to the witches and the wizards. As for those occult practitioners themselves, the witches and the wizards, the death penalty applies. They have made it their work to lead people away from the true Lord, let alone how their services are exceedingly dark and immoral acts. Some accounts suggest that they would provide poisons for assassination and abortifacients, as well as serve in sexual rituals intended to create copulation between humans and demons.

Moving on to verses 7 and 8, these two verses speak of being sanctified. Obviously, we heard a great deal about the sanctification of the tabernacle, its instruments, and the priests who operated therein, but there was also a sanctification for the common Israelite as well. To be sanctified means to take that which is basic and earthy, and setting it apart to be dedicated to higher and holier purposes. Thus, anyone who chooses to live a life defined first by their commitment to God is living a sanctified life. You might work in the world, but if in your work you seek to be honest and industrious, keeping your commitment to God to do fairly by your fellow man, then your worldly work is an act of sanctification to God.

Obviously dealing with the occult would be a form of unsanctification, but so would having any other idol as the chief interest in our daily affairs. Be it greed or pleasure or praise. Whatever we do towards those pursuits is unsanctified, even if it is religious in nature, and we run afoul of the injunctions in these verses.

Scriptural Analysis- Leviticus 17:10-12

10 And whatsoever man there be of the house of Israel, or of the strangers that sojourn among you, that eateth any manner of blood; I will even set my face against that soul that eateth blood, and will cut him off from among his people. 

11 For the life of the flesh is in the blood: and I have given it to you upon the altar to make an atonement for your souls: for it is the blood that maketh an atonement for the soul.

12 Therefore I said unto the children of Israel, No soul of you shall eat blood, neither shall any stranger that sojourneth among you eat blood.

Today’s verses reiterate God’s prohibition against the eating of blood. It is worth noting that this prohibition is different from the other laws regarding what meat was clean or unclean to eat. Those laws were about defining what sorts of animals were good, based on their possessing positive symbolic traits. Thus, clean animals were able to be eaten because they represented what was good, and unclean animals were not because they represented what was bad. But as we see in today’s verses, the blood wasn’t prohibited because it was bad, but because it represented something too sacred: life itself. And it wasn’t just the blood of unclean animals that was prohibited, but even of otherwise clean ones.

The prohibition of blood is therefore a lesson to us that not only should man eschew evil, but he also must not claim that which is too holy for him. It is exactly this sort of thinking that led to the abolition of slavery, as it entailed the possessing of another’s life, which was something too sacred for any man to own. And this is a principle that extends even to God. For even though He may claim our very lives, yet our obedience and our free will He still leaves as our own.

Thus, there is the outer sanctity that all of us are commanded to walk in the paths of, but there is also the inner sanctity, the sovreign soul that lives inside each of us, that no one else may lay claim to.

Transcended Life

One of the great quests of this life,
Is to find something that matters more to you than life,
Something for which you would give up your life.
For if you do not,
Then you haven’t transcended life.

If You Can Change One

If you can clean up your house, you can clean up your bad habits and build good ones instead.
If you can build good habits, you can build new friendships and cure your loneliness.
If you can cure your loneliness, you can cure your boredom and find something good to do.
If you can find something good to do, you can find something good to help others.
If you can help others, you can help your home have more peace and bring order to it.
If you can bring order to your home, you can bring order to your mind and calm it down.
If you can calm your mind down, you can calm your lusts and free your spirit.
If you can free your spirit, you can free the downtrodden and given them hope.
If you can give hope, you can give attention to what really matters.
If you can give attention to what really matters, you can give attention to God and praise Him.
If you can praise God, you can praise what is good in you and let Him purify your soul.
If you can let Him purify your soul, you can let Him purify your family and clean up your house.

If you can change but one, you can change them all.

A Choice of Integrity

A choice of integrity is a choice that I can live with for the long term and not hurt my conscience. If I am making a choice that I am willing to tolerate only for a time, but could not abide by permanently, then it is likely not a choice that I am making in integrity.

That is not to say that there cannot be changes of situation or perspective. It is possible to make one choice in integrity, and then with integrity change it afterward. It is also possible to recognize that one is entering a special season in life, and posture oneself accordingly, with the up-front understanding that after the season is over things will change.

But if from the outset I make a choice with the hope and expectation that those around me will change so that I do not have to abide by that choice any longer, then I have started without integrity. I am looking for outside sources to rescue me from my own decision, and that means I am making a violation against myself. I should not count on outside situations or people to change. I should ask myself what I would do from my conscience if they never changed, and the answer to that question is the choice of integrity.

The Best Lessons Must be Painful

The best lessons in life must be painful, because the best lessons require us to change. If they didn’t require us to change, they couldn’t be as meaningful as those that did. And to change means, to some degree, breaking and rebuilding. And breaking and rebuilding is painful.

So, if we are going through lessons that are painful, but which are causing us to change, it’s not that we are doing something wrong, we’re actually doing it exactly right. It’s just that growth is hard. That change is painful. It always has been this way, and it always will be.

Scriptural Analysis- Leviticus 3:16-17

16 And the priest shall burn them upon the altar: it is the food of the offering made by fire for a sweet savour: all the fat is the Lord’s.

17 It shall be a perpetual statute for your generations throughout all your dwellings, that ye eat neither fat nor blood.

This chapter ends with an interesting aside, where the Lord gives a commandment to the Israelites. Parts of these animals were never to be consumed by the Israelites. The Israelites were forbidden from consuming the blood of the animal, and from eating the fat. And it doesn’t seem to be because these parts were unclean or evil, but because they instead belonged to the Lord.

From other verses it is made clear that the blood was seen as containing the life itself of the animal. It was the sacred, animating factor that turned the creature from a heap of flesh and bones to a moving, acting thing. The fat, being the richest part of the animal, represented passion, energy, and drive. Thus, the animating factor in our lives, and our passion, energy, and drive, are to be seen as belonging to the Lord, not ourselves. We should not give our passion and life to our own desires, but reserve them for the higher purposes of God.

I don’t think that is just about reserving the best of ourselves for God. That could certainly be a part of it, but I believe it is also because the forces of life and passion are too strong for us to handle on our own. They are simply too potent, too powerful. We become drunk on our own passion and we flail about, trying to find some well that is deep enough to hold them. And so, we end up indulging in addiction, gambling, unsafe sex, vanity, greed, endless partying, and false causes. They are attractive to us because they are bottomless pits that we can pour our life and passion into forever, never mind the fact that they are unworthy vessels.

Thousands of years ago God showed His people a different endless well that we could pour their lives and passion into: Him. Just as the Israelites were warned not to try and stomach the fat and blood of the animal, but to surrender it to God instead, we are meant to direct our greatest energy and vitality to His cause, and it will be for our own good.

SacrificeEligible oblationStepsExplanation
Peace OfferingCattle, Lamb, GoatGratitude for reconciliation
Animal is slainGiving up old life for one of unity with another
Fat burned on altarGiving up old plans, passions, and drives

Full table.