The Gospel and the Death Penalty- Dangers of Interpretation

The Wages of Sin)

In my last post I examined each of the categories of sin for which God prescribed a death penalty. During my study I noticed a pattern that the death penalty seemed to be associated with sins that particularly defied the purpose of life, which purpose is to cultivate our souls into ones that can receive paradise. When a person detaches themselves from that divine purpose, they are no longer participating in life as it is intended, and God has the right to rescind that gift of life.

But even as I drew those conclusions, I knew there was an important issue to address. I saw how this line of thinking could be used to justify a whole slew of harsh and merciless policies. At the end of the day, all sin is an act of rebellion against God’s plan for us. All sin is contrary to the purpose for us being here. So, wouldn’t that justify the death penalty for all sin? Well, according to Romans 6:23, yes: “For the wages of sin is death.” It does not say only certain sin, it seems to mean all sin.

Furthermore, I can say from my own experiences that as I have been convicted of my own sins, I have felt that any penalty that God chose for me would be warranted. Be it death or be it hell, if God were to call for it, I could not say that He was unfair in so doing. I was very grateful to receive mercy instead, but I wasn’t entitled to it.

So yes, the death penalty can be argued as the just response for every sin that there is. Does that mean I would support a nation carrying out executions for every stolen library book, every angry insult, and every lustful thought? Well, no. That conclusion would be an incorrect interpretation of scripture. It would be focusing on just one aspect of the gospel, while ignoring all others.

Balance of Purpose)

Let us not forget, the whole point of my last post was that the death penalty could be justified for those who were no longer in agreement with the purpose of life, which purpose was to cultivate our souls to be fit for heaven. But we are imperfect beings, and all of us sin. To kill us all at the first offense would also frustrate the purpose of mortal life by cutting short our opportunity to repent and cultivate our souls. There clearly ought to be a threshold. Lesser sins, though still deserving of death, should have that penalty deferred so that there is a chance for repentance, while those who more seriously detach themselves from the purpose of life could still face immediate judgment.

And where should that threshold lie? How should we be able to tell when someone is in enough rebellion against the purpose of life to warrant death? These are questions that I do not need to answer. It is not in my jurisdiction. Life is created by God, and it is up to Him which penalties should apply to which violations. This is one of the reasons that the law was even given to Moses: so that God could answer these questions and His people would not have to make imperfect judgment calls of their own.

In summary, there is a justification for the death penalty for any sin. God would be justified wherever He applied that penalty, even for the most minor of offenses. It would be justified, but it would not be ideal for the accomplishment of His purposes. Wisdom therefore requires a threshold to allow both an opportunity for repentance and preservation of the natural order. It is God’s prerogative, and God’s prerogative alone, where that threshold should then be set.

Acknowledging the justification for the death penalty is not a carte blanche invitation for human authorities to kill all sinners. It does mean, though, that God has a field of choice in where to place the bounds of mercy and justice. He may even set one bound at one time, and adjust it at another, and that would be acceptable and appropriate. Which, of course, God appears to have done. He assigned the death penalty for adultery under the Law of Moses, but in the case of the woman taken in adultery, Jesus chose to extend mercy instead. Did something change? We will turn to that question in our next post.

The Gospel and the Death Penalty- Assumed Axioms of Morality

Fundamental Moral Beliefs)

Almost all of God’s commandments to His children have been criticized and deemphasized in our modern Western culture. People constantly make excuses for lying, cheating, and stealing. Yet the one sin that is still largely considered a sin is that of killing. Even today, people tend to be largely against the idea of one person killing another. In fact, we have built many hedges around this sin, becoming suspicious of all sorts of violence, be it getting into a fight or spanking a child. In almost every context, it is simply considered unacceptable to cause physical harm to another person.

Is it any wonder, then, that we see the exceptions that God makes for killing, where He directly orders His people to put others to death for egregious sins, and we feel that He is violating moral law? We have created a “higher” god than God, one who demands a higher principle of non-violence than He does, and therefore God Himself is seen as a transgressor. He violates that “more supreme” ethic and is therefore immoral.

We may not think about it in such terms, but at the end of the day this is the moral hierarchy that leads atheists to mock the God of the Bible and Christians to gloss over uncomfortable chapters. Both hold an internal moral ideal by which even God Himself is judged. And that ideal is so fundamental that they do not have to think or reason about it. It is embedded in their hearts, causing an immediate and visceral revulsion to anything that stands against it. Many of us take such instincts as being axioms of truth. The fact that our revulsion is so strong and involuntary must mean that our own ideals are fundamental, beyond scrutiny, just eternal facts.

Taking a Step Back)

However, just because something feels fundamental doesn’t mean that it is. People can absolutely be cultivated to have immediate, visceral reactions that would not be there under another context. There are numerous examples of this, so let us mention a few. People that are raised around a particular race often feel unsettled when first seeing a person with another skin color, but had they been raised in a more diverse place no involuntary reaction would occur. People raised eating one country’s food may have an involuntary gag reflex when eating the food items of another country, though natives of that foreign land eat it without any trouble. A person raised to keep their room tidy will be deeply uncomfortable in the room of a pack rat, yet the pack rat feels absolutely relaxed in that setting. In each of these examples, we realize that these strong and involuntary negative reactions are not an indication of universal moral truth, but a result of conditioning.

This isn’t to say that all of our instincts are purely environmental. I believe that some of them truly do point to universal truth. But it is important to understand that the existence of the negative instinct is not proof in-and-of-itself that the reviled thing is immoral. We might just be out of tune.

When we are brought up in a strong culture, there are elements of it that are just too close for us to recognize. We have to take a step back and adjust our perspective to realize which things we just assumed to be true, but which might not have been. I would not expect anyone from my culture to read all of the death penalties that God assigned in the Old Testament and not feel that initial wave of revulsion. At this point those feelings are inevitable. But I do think it is worth considering whether those feelings are the result of eternal moral truth, or merely the conditioning of a particularly violence-avoidant culture.

The Gospel and the Death Penalty- An Uncomfortable Problem

An Inconvenient Chapter)

Recently in my scripture study I covered Leviticus 20, which requires the death penalty for certain transgressions. Some of the applications of this penalty are fairly uncontroversial, such as consigning to death any man who performs human sacrifice with his own children. Others are extremely controversial in our modern day, such as prescribing death for cursing one’s parents, blaspheming the name of the Lord, engaging in homosexual relations, or committing adultery.

I know many Christians who choose not to contend with this area of the gospel at all. They essentially say, “Well, that was just the Old Testament, the real gospel began with Jesus.” This, of course, overlooks the fact that the lawgiver of the Old Testament is Jehovah, who is the same person as Jesus Christ. Thus, if one approves of Christ’s ethics because of the New Testament, but disapproves of his ethics because of the Old Testament, then they are contradicting themselves.

Those that do not hold to sola scriptura (the belief that the Bible has remained the pure, unaltered word of God throughout all history), tend to throw out difficult chapters of the Bible, such as Leviticus 20, claiming that this must be a chapter fabricated by men, and not the will of God. Even though I do not hold to sola scriptura myself, I believe it is a grave error to so casually discard these passages. For one thing, there is no evidence of this chapter being fabricated except for personal discomfort with it. Also, passages that usually are accepted, such as the woman taken in adultery, make it clear that the death penalty for such sins was a genuine law in Jesus’s time, and one that he did not call out as being a false doctrine, even though he did so for other man-made laws.

Jesus Divided?)

Of course, the example of the woman taken in adultery further complicates things. In that story, Jesus does not say, “don’t kill her, that’s false doctrine,” but at the same time he does find a path that spares her the death penalty. And Christians today follow his example by not seeking to kill every blasphemer or adulterer. If we accept that the Jehovah of the Old Testament said what He said, and that the Jesus of the New Testament pardoned what he pardoned, are we left with the same being contradicting himself? Does Jesus’s mercy frustrate Jehovah’s justice? Or is there something larger at play here that often goes overlooked?

I believe that there is. I will spend the next couple posts going into detail on this matter, but to cut to the chase, I believe that the sacrifice of Jesus is the fulfillment of every death penalty for every mortal sin. I do not believe that Jesus and Jehovah contradict one another. I believe that Jehovah’s death penalty is still in full force to this day, only it is executed upon Jesus instead of us. This perspective neatly resolves any seeming contradiction in divinity, leaving us only to come to terms with the fact that absent Christ’s sacrifice, the death penalty for certain sins would still be the divine mandate today.

I will dig into that matter with tomorrow’s post. If Jehovah’s death penalties are just and correct in principle, why do they feel so wrong to us today?

Scriptural Analysis- Leviticus 20:17, 19-21

17 And if a man shall take his sister, his father’s daughter, or his mother’s daughter, and see her nakedness, and she see his nakedness; it is a wicked thing; and they shall be cut off in the sight of their people: he hath uncovered his sister’s nakedness; he shall bear his iniquity. 

19 And thou shalt not uncover the nakedness of thy mother’s sister, nor of thy father’s sister: for he uncovereth his near kin: they shall bear their iniquity.

20 And if a man shall lie with his uncle’s wife, he hath uncovered his uncle’s nakedness: they shall bear their sin; they shall die childless.

21 And if a man shall take his brother’s wife, it is an unclean thing: he hath uncovered his brother’s nakedness; they shall be childless.

Today’s verses continue with other abominable sexual relationships between near kin, but I grouped these together as the ones that were of a lesser offense, given that none of them carry a death penalty. There is being cut off, bearing one’s iniquity, and dying childless, but no execution for approaching one’s sister, aunt, stepmother, or sister-in-law. This makes sense, as none of the natural effects of these acts are as ruinous to the bloodline or the community as those mentioned earlier.

The last prohibition against taking a brother’s wife is interesting, because Ancient Israel observed Levirate marriage, in which if a man died, his widow could be married to one of his near kin, including his brother, and any children born to that union would be raised under the deceased brother’s line. It would seem that the prohibition in verse 21 is excluding that particular instance. Or…maybe not. Since any children born to this union would belong to the original husband’s clan, the brother would remain legally childless in that relationship, though the sister-in-law would not.

This brings us to the end of penalties for perverse sexual relations. It is clear that the power of giving life was sacred and closely guarded, with clear and numerous laws to preserve it for the manner that God has prescribed since the creation of Adam and Eve. It is not an evil power, but it is a power that can be used evilly. And when it is, the natural ramifications on the home, the bloodline, and the society are severe, thus the penalties associated are similarly severe.

Scriptural Analysis- Leviticus 20:10, 13, 15, 16, 18

10 And the man that committeth adultery with another man’s wife, even he that committeth adultery with his neighbour’s wife, the adulterer and the adulteress shall surely be put to death. 

13 If a man also lie with mankind, as he lieth with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination: they shall surely be put to death; their blood shall be upon them.

15 And if a man lie with a beast, he shall surely be put to death: and ye shall slay the beast.

16 And if a woman approach unto any beast, and lie down thereto, thou shalt kill the woman, and the beast: they shall surely be put to death; their blood shall be upon them.

18 And if a man shall lie with a woman having her sickness, and shall uncover her nakedness; he hath discovered her fountain, and she hath uncovered the fountain of her blood: and both of them shall be cut off from among their people.

We now move into the verses prohibiting various sexual relations, much like the ones we just saw in Leviticus 18. The main difference is that this chapter includes punishments for each of these crimes. Not every punishment is the same, and so we learn which sexual relations were more egregious and we can hypothesize as to why.

This category of sin covers verses 10 through 21, and I have decided to rearrange the verses to group them by categories that stood out to me during my study. Today includes all the examples of sex with someone or something who is not a close relation. Most prohibitions have to do with those familial relationships, but there were other aberrant relationships also called out, almost all of them with a death penalty attached.

Specifically, adultery with an unrelated person, male homosexuality, and bestiality were all relationships that would result in the death of both parties. As I consider these, I see a pattern emerge. Each of these sexual acts is tended towards a sort of end or extinction. Homosexual males and people who have sex with animals cannot reproduce, their desires lead to the end of a line, not the continuation of it. Adultery can produce children, but it confuses bloodlines and dissolves the family identity. Each of these aberrant behaviors are already naturally dead acts, and assigning the penalty of death emphasizes that fact.

And then, of course, there is the example of having sex with a woman during her period. This, too, is a non-reproductive act, given that the woman’s body is incapable of fertilization at this time. Even so, the penalty for this act is not death, and that makes sense, given that the sexual union of man and woman is still of the type to reproduce, it’s just the timing that is wrong, whereas all the other acts are not even of the type to reproduce, no matter the timing.

With these laws God seems to be acknowledging a fundamental principle of the universe. It is good and life-giving to be of the type that can reproduce. Those that choose to live after the manner of extinction or act only in impotence are in transgression of their very nature. They live according to death.

Scriptural Analysis- Leviticus 6:1-7

1 And the Lord spake unto Moses, saying,

2 If a soul sin, and commit a trespass against the Lord, and lie unto his neighbour in that which was delivered him to keep, or in fellowship, or in a thing taken away by violence, or hath deceived his neighbour;

3 Or have found that which was lost, and lieth concerning it, and sweareth falsely; in any of all these that a man doeth, sinning therein:

4 Then it shall be, because he hath sinned, and is guilty, that he shall restore that which he took violently away, or the thing which he hath deceitfully gotten, or that which was delivered him to keep, or the lost thing which he found,

5 Or all that about which he hath sworn falsely; he shall even restore it in the principal, and shall add the fifth part more thereto, and give it unto him to whom it appertaineth, in the day of his trespass offering.

6 And he shall bring his trespass offering unto the Lord, a ram without blemish out of the flock, with thy estimation, for a trespass offering, unto the priest:

7 And the priest shall make an atonement for him before the Lord: and it shall be forgiven him for any thing of all that he hath done in trespassing therein.

A few days ago we started examining what I have called the “higher trespass offering,” and the offenses described for it seemed ambiguous. I mentioned in that initial post that the descriptions become much clearer in this chapter. Here we see that if an Israelite cheated something away from his neighbor, in any way, that would make him guilty of having “deceitfully gotten,” and he would remain guilty until this higher trespass offering was made.

There are many ways in which a man might be guilty of this, and the verses go at some length to describe them, but what is most important is that principle of “deceitfully gotten.” In whatever way you managed to acquire your neighbor’s possession, if it was “deceitfully gotten,” you are in the wrong.

It is interesting to note that a cost was applied to the sin itself in how the perpetrator must “add the fifth part” of the item’s value to its restoration. This is different from the laws of “an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth,” where the restitution was meant to be exactly equal to the offense. The key difference between those laws and these is that “an eye for an eye” applied to the destruction and replacement of another person’s property. In today’s case, no permanent destruction took place, so the original item could be returned without replacement. If that was the end of it, then there would be no consideration for the inconvenience to the victim or the ill-gotten benefit of the perpetrator. By telling the perpetrator to “add the fifth part,” you essentially turned the theft into a pricey loan, and the victim gets a rich return.

I have included these first seven verses with my analysis of Chapter 5 because they clearly belong with the second half of that chapter. Verse 8 begins an entirely new subject, and so ought to be considered the true beginning of the next chapter. Thus, I will take my usual intra-chapter interlude here and resume my scriptural analysis next week.

SacrificeEligible oblationStepsExplanation
Higher trespass offeringRam, moneyRestitution for taking from one’s neighbor. Possibly other special cases also.
Ram presumably slaughtered and burnedPresumably spiritual cleansing or restoration
Payment of moneyRestitution for damage and a fine

Scriptural Analysis- Exodus 22:1, 4

1 If a man shall steal an ox, or a sheep, and kill it, or sell it; he shall restore five oxen for an ox, and four sheep for a sheep.

4 If the theft be certainly found in his hand alive, whether it be ox, or ass, or sheep; he shall restore double.

In the previous chapter we heard all the laws related to killing. These laws covered both the killing of people and of livestock, and both the intentional and the unintentional variances of each. Today’s verses now shift from killing to stealing, and there are some interesting moral lessons to be gleaned here.

The first that stands out to me is that the penalty for the deliberate theft of an animal is substantially greater than the penalty we already read for the accidental killing of an animal. It is a key moral principle that the penalty is not based only on what the outcome was (the loss of the animal), but what the underlying motivation behind that outcome were. The penalty is according to the man’s guilt more than the deprivation that was suffered.

Also, note how in the second verse it says that a thief found with the animal still alive is required to return the creature, and then one also of his own. We already heard the principle of an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth, and this is consistent with that. Since this man had sought to reduce his neighbor’s livestock by one, now he shall experience what it is to have one of his herd reduced by one instead.

And finally, note how the penalty is even worse if the thief has already sold the creature away, or killed it, before he is caught. Now, instead of returning the creature and being out one of his own, he must now give up four or five of his animals. I assume the significantly more severe punishment is because the thief stole with the intention to destroy. He didn’t just take from the rightful owner, he took it out to where it could not ever be given back to the owner. That is a darker sin than to have taken, but to have left the door open for remorse and restoration.