The Gospel and the Death Penalty- Why Death?

Death Penalty Categories)

I have spent the last two posts addressing different categories of people who would be opposed to God’s use of the death penalty in the Old Testament. Today, I am going to take up the other side. Why would God use the death penalty? Are there justifiable reasons for its application to the situations described in the Bible? Let’s start by considering what those situations are.

God’s application of the death penalty falls under five general categories:

  1. Sexual perversion: adultery, homosexuality, bestiality, incest, etc.
  2. Violence: murder, kidnapping, etc.
  3. Idolatry: performing witchcraft or wizardry, worshipping false gods, leading others astray, etc.
  4. Disobedience to God: blaspheming God, working on the Sabbath, disobeying the priest, etc.
  5. Disobedience to parents: cursing parents, striking parents, stubbornly rebellious child, etc.

If I were to abstract this further, I think the category of sexual perversion could be called actions against nature, the violence category could be called retributive justice, and all of the other categories could be summed up as open rebellion. I believe that abstracting these categories is useful for understanding the principle of offense at the heart of them, the core thing in each that God is so opposed to. Let us look at each of these three abstracted categories in turn.

Three Underlying Principles)

The first category is sins against nature. God has created the world with a natural order. Each species reproduces with its own kind. Family units progress from one generation to the next. Everything fulfills God’s original command to be fruitful and multiply. Our nature is one of life and propagation. Therefore, sins that go against the natural order are actions oriented towards death and termination. The end of reproduction, the end of a family line, the breaking up of the natural order…each of these is a small death, and if adopted by a significant portion of the species would spell the end of it very quickly. Thus, those who engage in sins against nature, particularly through sexually deviant acts, are already agents of death, and it is fitting for a death penalty to be assigned to them. It is God recognizing the ends that these acts are oriented towards and enacting that end immediately.

The second category is retributive justice. These are sins that deprive another of life, and therefore it is only fitting that the penalty for it is also death. This obviously includes murder, but kidnapping and selling into slavery are also forms of taking another’s life, just in a more symbolic way. Even leading others astray from the faith is a sort of killing: the killing of the soul. That sin fits in this category just as well as the next. To require the life of those that commit these killing acts is nothing more than basic justice. It is an eye for an eye. You were willing to deprive others of life, so your life is required as well.

The final category is that of open rebellion. As with the first category, God gave us another natural order of hierarchy and power. Children are subject to parents. Citizens are subject to leaders. Humanity is subject to God. Instructions and care flow down one direction of the order, fealty and obedience flow the other way. When one comes out in rebellion, they deny their proper place in that order. They hold themselves as the highest authority and sever their link from the chain. Not only have they cut themselves off, but they make themselves an enemy to the established order. They wrest for control, which makes them a direct antithesis to the order. No order can continue if its subjects can defy it unabated. When rebellion begins, it must mean the death of the order or of the rebel. God has prescribed the death of the rebel.

The Final Abstraction)

Looking at all of these categories as one, another final abstraction emerges. God created this world for the cultivation of His children, to place them within an order and nature that encourage growth, development, and ultimately for them to achieve their greatest potential. That is the whole purpose of us being here. Each of these categories of sin directly frustrates that plan. They are inherently opposed to the continuation and cultivation of God’s children. When a system has been created for a purpose, then any subject no longer interested in participating in that system does not belong within it. If one does not wish to participate in the purpose of life, then being removed from life is understandable. Yes, that analysis is clinical and cold, but I think it is also logically sound. We are here for a reason, and if we no longer fulfill that reason, why we expect to remain here?

Of course, that raises some questions. Where is the line between simply being imperfect and not being aligned to our purpose for being here? Could the arguments that I have made today be used to justify terrible atrocities? It is also worth asking, if this is the system and the order that God has designed, then why was it removed after the coming of Christ? Why do we not follow this same logic today? We will dig into these sorts of questions in my next post.

Scriptural Analysis- Exodus 32:28, 30

28 And the children of Levi did according to the word of Moses: and there fell of the people that day about three thousand men.

30 And it came to pass on the morrow, that Moses said unto the people, Ye have sinned a great sin: and now I will go up unto the Lord; peradventure I shall make an atonement for your sin.

It is not entirely clear who the three thousand killed by the Levites were. This verse and the following ones suggest that there still remained some of those Israelites who had participated in the act of idolatry. Indeed, if the entire camp, (or even just a significant fraction of the camp) had participated, then there would have been anywhere from tens of thousands to millions of idolaters still standing after the previous day’s slaughter.

It may be that when Moses returned the majority of the people were ambivalent as to whether or not they would return to serving the Lord, but that three thousand stood against Moses, and were prepared to defend their licentiousness by force. I think it is notable that the three thousand that were slain were “men,” which sounds to me like it might have been an army of rebels that had to be put down before the rest of the people gave way to Moses.

In either case, it seems clear from verse 30 that there were still many left alive who were soiled with sin. Moses, who had been the fierce sword of justice on the day before, now became the merciful advocate. Having seen for himself the weight of the people’s sin, he would return yet again to the mountain, in order to plead their case before the Lord.

Scriptural Analysis- Genesis 14:1-5, 8, 10

1 And it came to pass in the days of Amraphel king of Shinar, Arioch king of Ellasar, Chedorlaomer king of Elam, and Tidal king of nations;

2 That these made war with Bera king of Sodom, and with Birsha king of Gomorrah, Shinab king of Admah, and Shemeber king of Zeboiim, and the king of Bela, which is Zoar.

3 All these were joined together in the vale of Siddim, which is the salt sea.

4 Twelve years they served Chedorlaomer, and in the thirteenth year they rebelled.

5 And in the fourteenth year came Chedorlaomer, and the kings that were with him, and smote the Rephaims in Ashteroth Karnaim, and the Zuzims in Ham, and the Emims in Shaveh Kiriathaim,

8 And there went out the king of Sodom, and the king of Gomorrah, and the king of Admah, and the king of Zeboiim, and the king of Bela (the same is Zoar;) and they joined battle with them in the vale of Siddim;

10 And the vale of Siddim was full of slimepits; and the kings of Sodom and Gomorrah fled, and fell there; and they that remained fled to the mountain.

I mentioned previously that we probably only hear about this war in the Bible because of how it intersected with the story of Abram. Surely there were other wars that were glossed over or left out entirely. But since we do have a record of this war, I thought it would be fitting to provide a small recap of what exactly transpired.

Lot, Abram’s nephew had gone to live in the city of Sodom, which was a vassal state to the kingdom of Elam. There were several other cities that were subservient to the kingdom of Elam as well, including Gomorrah. Eventually, several of those vassal cities decided to throw off their overlord, resulting in the ruler of Elam, King Chedorlaomer, rallying his loyal subjects and giving the rebels a sound beating. The rulers of Sodom and Gomorrah fell in battle, their cities were pillaged, and citizens that hadn’t even been involved in the fight, such as Lot and his household, were taken captive by the conquering horde.

A truth that is repeated many times throughout the Bible is that a great burden of responsibility sits upon every ruler, for the follies of a foolish king are most often paid for by his subjects. Even to this day, a wise ruler is the greatest blessing that can be given to a nation, and a foolhardy one its greatest curse.

Scriptural Analysis- Genesis 14:1-5, 8, 10

1 And it came to pass in the days of Amraphel king of Shinar, Arioch king of Ellasar, Chedorlaomer king of Elam, and Tidal king of nations;

2 That these made war with Bera king of Sodom, and with Birsha king of Gomorrah, Shinab king of Admah, and Shemeber king of Zeboiim, and the king of Bela, which is Zoar.

3 All these were joined together in the vale of Siddim, which is the salt sea.

4 Twelve years they served Chedorlaomer, and in the thirteenth year they rebelled.

5 And in the fourteenth year came Chedorlaomer, and the kings that were with him, and smote the Rephaims in Ashteroth Karnaim, and the Zuzims in Ham, and the Emims in Shaveh Kiriathaim,


8 And there went out the king of Sodom, and the king of Gomorrah, and the king of Admah, and the king of Zeboiim, and the king of Bela (the same is Zoar;) and they joined battle with them in the vale of Siddim;

10 And the vale of Siddim was full of slimepits; and the kings of Sodom and Gomorrah fled, and fell there; and they that remained fled to the mountain.

I mentioned yesterday that we probably only even hear about this war in the Bible because of how it intersected with the story of Abram. Surely there were other wars and events that are glossed over or even left entirely unmentioned.

But since we do have a record of this war, I thought it would be fitting to provide a small recap of what exactly transpired.

Lot, Abram’s nephew had gone to live in the city of Sodom, which was a vassal state to the kingdom of Elam. Gomorrah was also subservient to the kingdom of Elam, as well as several other great cities. And at the time of this story several of these vassal cities decided to throw off their overlords. The ruler of Elam, King Chedorlaomer, rallied his loyal subjects and made war with these rebels, in which the uprising was given a sound beating. The rulers of Sodom and Gomorrah fell, and their cities pillaged. During which pillaging, Lot and his household were taken captive by the conquering horde.

There is a great burden of responsibility upon every ruler. The follies of a foolish king are most often paid for by his subjects, whether they were themselves innocent or guilty. Those of us who have the privilege of electing our own rulers should consider that a great blessing, and we should be very studious only those who are wise.